Image-8 If Logic 2

stop sign

If With Color



The Problem With (red > 160) Test

Trying to change the stop sign to be blue, the test (red > 160) gets both white and red areas. The problem with that approach is that the red value is high in two kinds of cases -- the red part of the sign we want, but also parts of the scene that are near white. Recall that pure white is (255, 255, 255), so in whitish areas, all three values are high, so our (red > 160) test gets those too -- the white letters inside the sign are a clear example of this problem. Next we'll improve the test so it can distinguish the red and white parts of the sign.

Color Bars

Suppose we have three pixels. Each pixel has the familiar red/green/blue values. Suppose these three values are graphed as bar graphs like this:

red/green/blue bar graphs of three pixels

Q: What color is the strongest for each pixel?

Look at the graphs to figure which shade dominates for each pixel. Find the tallest bar relative to the others. The problem with our earlier strategy was that it just looked at absolute numbers, (red > 160), failing to take into account how red relates to the other two colors.

Recall Average of Pixel Color

Recall this code which, inside a loop, computes the average of the red, blue, and green values and stores that number in a variable "avg".

  avg = (pixel.getRed() + pixel.getGreen() + pixel.getBlue())/3;

Color Bars With Average

Here are the three pixels again, but now the avg value is show as a line drawn across the bars.

red/green/blue bar graphs with avg shown

The avg gives us a handy way to tell if a color is high relative to the others: A pixel is reddish if the red value is over the avg.

So here the first pixel is reddish and the other two are not. Or in terms of code, the test will look like (pixel.getRed() > avg) -- this will add the "relative to the other colors" quality that the previous test was missing.

Color Avg Test Example - Stop



This is a better way to select the red parts of the sign. For each pixel, first compute the average value for that pixel. Then compare the red value to the average to decide if the pixel is reddish. Rather than checking the literal value of the red (e.g. 160), this checks if the red is relatively large compared to the other two colors .. does the pixel lean towards red. If the test is (pixel.getRed() > avg) we get all the areas that have every a tiny red cast, which is not restrictive enough. The fix is to multiply the avg by some factor to make it more restrictive, like this: (pixel.getRed() > avg * 1.1). The specific value, 1.1, can be tuned by trying different values, until we get the look we want. Try the values: 0.9, 1.2, 1.4, 2, 2.5. The larger the value, the higher the bar is set to detect red pixels. By adjusting the * factor, we can zero in on the look we want. Here I think 1.4 looks pretty good.

Color Avg Test You Try It - Curb

Suppose you are visiting Stanford and you park your car here, and get a parking ticket. Philosophically, they say that you are better off taking in events as they have actually happened. Nonetheless, here we'll try to fix history in code.
red curb

Challenge: write code to detect the red curb, tuning the 1.1 factor to look the best. Then (a) change the curb to medium gray red=120 green=120 blue=120. (b) change just the curb to be grayscale, which will look more realistic. Rather than changing the whole image to grayscale, we change just the red areas.



Solution code (a):

// This solution looks the best to me for (b).
image = new SimpleImage("curb.jpg");
for (pixel: image) {
  avg = (pixel.getRed() + pixel.getGreen() + pixel.getBlue())/3;

  if (pixel.getRed() > avg * 1.1) {