Nick Carter, Detective: The Solution of a Remarkable Case
THE MURDER IN FORTY-SEVENTH STREET.
The city of New York was electrified one evening by the news that one
of its greatest favorites had been foully murdered.
Eugenie La Verde had been found dead in her room and the murderer had
not left a single clew, however slight, by which he could be traced.
Mademoiselle La Verde had been before the public for two seasons as a
danseuse, and by her remarkable beauty and modesty, as well as by the
unparalleled grace with which she executed her inimitable steps she had
won her way to the hearts of all.
On the evening preceding her death she had danced as usual, winning
round after round of applause, and a deluge of flowers.
Immediately after the performance she had been driven to her home in
Forty-seventh street, accompanied only by her maid, who had been with
her for many years, and who scarcely ever left her presence.
The maid had attended her as usual that night; had remained with her
until she had disrobed, and then, at her mistress' request, had given
her a book, and retired.
Eugenie had bade her servant good-night as usual, adding the injunction
that she did not wish to be disturbed before ten o'clock on the
At ten o'clock precisely on the morning of the succeeding day, the maid,
whose name was Delia Dent, had gone to her mistress' room to assist her
in dressing, and upon entering, had been so horrified by the sight that
met her gaze that she had swooned away then and there.
Eugenie La Verde was lying upon her bed, clad in the soft wrapper which
the maid had helped her to don before leaving her on the preceding
Her face was distorted and swollen almost beyond recognition, and in
spots was highly discolored, where the blood had coagulated beneath the
skin. Her mouth was open, and her eyes were wide and staring, even yet
filled with an expression of the horror through which she had passed
just before her death. Her delicate hands, pretty enough for an artist's
model, were clenched until the finger-nails had sunk into the tender
flesh and drawn blood. The figure bore every evidence of a wild and
terrific Struggle to escape from the grasp in which she had been seized,
while the dull blue mark around her throat told only too plainly how her
death had been accomplished.
The bed bore every evidence of a wild and terrific struggle. The
coverings were tumbled in great confusion, one pillow had fallen upon
the floor, and the book which the murdered girl had been engaged in
reading when the grip of the assassin had seized her, was torn and
Eugenie was dead, and everything in the room bore mute evidence that she
had died horribly, and that she had struggled desperately to free
herself from the attack of her slayer.
In searching for evidence of the presence of the murderer, not a clew of
any kind could be found.
How he had gained access to the room where the danseuse was reading, or
how he had left it after consummating the horrible deed, were mysteries
which the keenest detectives failed to fathom
Theories were as plenty as mosquitoes in June, but there was positively
no proof in support of any of, them, and one by one they fell to the
ground and were abandoned as useless or absurd.
As a last resort, Delia Dent, the maid, fell under the ban of suspicion.
But only for a time. The most stupid of investigators could not long
believe her guilty of a crime so heinous, while, moreover, it was
certain that she was not possessed of the necessary physical strength to
accomplish the deed.
Neither had she the will power, for beyond her love for her dead
mistress, the woman was weak and yielding in her nature.
Delia Dent did not long survive her mistress.
The terrible shock caused by the discovery of Eugenie's dead body was
more than her frail strength could bear. She was prostrated nervously,
and after growing steadily worse for a period of four weeks, she died at
the hospital where she had been taken.
One theory, which for a time found many supporters,
was that Delia Dent had been in league with the murderer; had admitted
him to the house, and had allowed him quietly to depart after the deed
But that theory was also abandoned, as being even more absurd than the
others that had been advanced. Delia was conscious to the last, during
her sickness, at the hospital, and just before her death she devised all
her savings-a sum amounting to nearly ten thousand dollars-to her
lawyer, in trust for the person who should succeed in bringing the
murderer of Eugenie La Verde to justice. The house in Forty-seventh
street, where Eugenie had been killed, was, at the time, occupied solely
and the maid Delia, and the basement was never used by them at all. Once
a month the man who examined the gas-meter came to attend to his duty,
and upon such occasions he passed through the basement hall on his way
to the cellar. But when his work was done, Delia always locked and
chained the door which communicated between the basement and the parlor
floor, and it was never again disturbed until the same necessity arose
during the following month.
Eugenie never dined at home, and her maid never left her. Her breakfast,
which consisted only of coffee and a roll, was always prepared by the
maid over an alcoholic lamp in the room where Eugenie slept.
After the discovery of the crime, a careful examination was made of
every window and door in the house which communicated by any possibility
with the outside world.
All were found securely locked, and every door was provided with the
additional security afforded by a chain.
Even the scuttle had an intricate padlock:
Nothing had been molested.
Window-fastenings, door-locks, chain-bolts, scuttle and sky-light were
From the circumstances of the case as they were discovered after the
commission of the crime, it was absolutely impossible for the murderer
to have gained access to the house without leaving some evidence of the
fact. Again, supposing the assassin to have been already concealed
therein, it was equally impossible that he could have gotten out without
furnishing some clew.
Delia Dent, as has been said, had fainted when she discovered the dead
body of her young mistress. Upon reviving, she had staggered to a
messenger call in the hallway, having barely strength to ring for the
police. Then, still half-fainting, she had managed to reach the foot of
the stairs, but had not yet unchained the front door when her call was
answered. She believed that she fainted twice, or that site was in a
state of semi-consciousness during the interval that elapsed between the
discovery of the crime and the arrival of the police.
The more thorough the investigation, the deeper grew the mystery.
Old and tried detectives were put upon the case. At first they looked
wise and assured everybody of the speedy apprehension of the fiend who
had committed the deed. Then they became puzzled, and finally utterly
confounded. The bravest of them at last confessed that they were no
nearer the truth than at the beginning, and one of them, the shrewdest
of all, boldly stated that the only way in
which the assassin would ever be discovered would be by his voluntary
confession, which was not likely to ensue.
Thus matters drifted on until the public mind found other things to
think of. The papers at first devoted pages to the event; then a few
columns. In a week, one column sufficed. Finally the reports dwindled
down to a single comment, and then to nothing, and the mysterious murder
was practically relegated to history and forgotten.
There was one, however, who had not forgotten it, and that one was the
Inspector in Chief, at Police Headquarters.
Every resource at his command had been exhausted. His best men had taken
the case in hand and failed. He had personally given all the time he
could spare from his other duties to the murder of Eugenie La Verde,
and was yet as greatly mystified as ever. There was no palpable or
reasonable solution to the problem.
Her jewels, of great value, were found untouched upon the dressing-case.
A roll of bills amounting to several hundred dollars was in the top
drawer, where it had evidently been carelessly thrown by the murdered
girl that very night.
The murderer had doubtless approached stealthily, giving her no warning.
He had seized her in his vise-like grip, choked her to death, and left
her as stealthily as he had come. Her body was undefiled by bruises,
contusions, or other marks, showing that he had given his attention
solely to the work of killing. It was even evident that he had not
sought to put a stop to her struggles by the exercise of physical
violence, other than that of choking his Victim.
The marks upon her throat were peculiar and very striking.
Some of the detectives thought that the assassin had used both hands
simultaneously; others believed that he had made use of a rope, holding
one end in either hand and winding it twice around her neck.
There was one fact which seemed to upset every theory that was advanced.
The door between the room and the hall-way was closed, although not
The bed on which Eugenie was murdered was so situated that it would have
been absolutely impossible for anyone to enter the room without being
seen by her. The gas was brilliantly lighted, and was so found in the
morning after the crime. Delia Dent had never known her mistress to fall
asleep while reading, or to neglect to extinguish the gas when ready to
compose herself for the night.
Was there a third person in the house, whose presence was known to her
Preposterous! Delia could not have failed to be aware of such a fact,
and the person could not have left the house without being discovered,
or leaving traces of his manner of exit.
Nothing had. ever been whispered against the character of Eugenie La
Verde, and the coroner's inquest proved that she had been worthy of her
reputation for modesty and purity.
The crime was a month old when, one evening shortly after dark,
Inspector Byrnes went quietly up the steps of Nick Carter's residence.
Everybody believed that the chief had given the matter up, and he was
perfectly willing that the public should have that opinion.
In the meantime, he had decided that there was one man in New York who
might be able to solve the mystery.
Hence, his quiet call upon Nick Carter.