Narrowing the Competence-Performance Gap: Syntax as Time-linear Growth of Semantic Representation
This paper shows how with syntax defined as progressive projection of semantic representations along the left-right dimension provided by the sequence of words (Cann et al 2005), natural explanations can be provided for local and (multiple) nonlocal scrambling of NPs in Japanese and Korean which follow from general principles of tree growth, explaining differences between the languages while nevertheless retaining an integrated account of scrambling itself (following Kiaer 2007, Kempson and Kiaer forthcoming). This formalism has many similarities with the parsing mechanism of Miyamoto 2002, but goes further in using such mechanisms as the base grammar formalism. In place of concepts of movement, concepts of structural underspecification representing partial semantic representations are invoked, with growth of such structure within a derivation following the time-linear dynamics of parsing. The account extends the Cann et al analysis of Japanese scrambling to encompass multiple long-distance dependency, capturing both the attendant relative locality restriction on the constituents moved, and the interaction of this restriction with scopeconstrual effects. Scope construal variability is straightforwardly expressible as interaction between individual lexical specifications for the two languages and general constraints on scope construal; and the relative locality constraint on the construal of the expressions involved in multiple long-distance dependency is shown to follow as an immediate consequence of the general dynamics of the framework. The result is an account within the Hawkins program of defining grammars relative to performance considerations.
- Cann, R. Kempson, R. and L. Marten 2005. The Dynamics of Language. Elsevier
- Hawkins, J. 2004 Efficiency and Complexity in Grammars. OUP.
- Kempson, R. and J. Kiaer forthcoming. Multiple long-distance scrambling: syntax as reflections of processing. Journal of Linguistics 46.
- Kiaer, J. 2007 Processing and Interfaces in Syntactic Theory: the case of Korean. Ph.D., King's College London.
- Miyamoto, E. 2002. Case markers as clause boundary inducers in Japanese. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 31, 307-47.