Assignment 9

A9Heuristic Evaluation Synthesis

Three evaluators from other teams reviewed our medium-fi prototype against 12 heuristics. They found 55 issues. Here is every one, ranked by severity, with their top recommendations.

Published55 violations3 evaluators12 heuristics

01 · Overview

Most issues were about feedback and consistency

Open the table under the chart for the severity split and full heuristic names.

Violations per heuristic

Show as a table
HeuristicSev 3Sev 2Sev 1Sev 0Total
H1: Visibility of System Status235010
H2: Match b/w System & World32207
H3: User Control & Freedom42006
H4: Consistency & Standards14308
H5: Error Prevention02204
H6: Recognition not Recall13105
H7: Flexibility & Efficiency of Use00202
H8: Aesthetic & Minimalist Design02204
H9: Help Users with Errors01001
H10: Help & Documentation01113
H11: Accessible Design03003
H12: Value Alignment & Inclusion02002
Total112518155

Severity 3 · major

11

Severity 2 · minor

25

Severity 1 · cosmetic

18

Severity 0 · note

1

Top three heuristics

  • H1 Visibility of system status: 10
  • H4 Consistency and standards: 8
  • H2 Match between system and world: 7

No issues were rated 4 (catastrophe). Many low-severity issues come from hard-coded medium-fi data, like the streak changing from 5 to 7 to 6.

02 · Recommendations

What the evaluators told us

"Trunkate is super cute and has a really clear, friendly idea! The look is cohesive, with Trunk giving the app a warm personality."Evaluators' summary

Recommendation 1

Let people say no to Trunk

Every suggestion needs a second option next to the main one, and anything you log should be undoable. An app that rearranges a busy person's schedule without asking can feel controlling.

Recommendation 2

Make the plan's limits visible

Show minutes per session and how long the whole plan runs. Lead each step with the step itself, not the week range. Busy people plan around time, so this builds trust in the AI.

Recommendation 3

Don't assume the week went badly

The weekly review only asks what got in the way. It should also let people say the week went well.

Also

Polish the visuals

Make screens consistent and clean up hard-coded data before hi-fi testing, so testers aren't distracted by numbers that don't add up.

Patterns across the issues

  • Actions often aren't confirmed afterward.
  • Forms accept contradictory or empty input.
  • Visual hierarchy gives too much weight to less important information.
  • Users get pushed forward with no way back.

03 · Major issues

The 11 severity-3 problems

These are the problems to fix first for the high-fi prototype.

SeverityHeuristicTaskProblemSuggested fix
3H1SimpleOn the "Start weekly review: screen, clicking "Looks good" does not appear to trigger an action or provide confirmation that the updated schedule has been saved. also is this button always present or does it show up once a week then disappear?show maybe a tick on the button after you completed the weekly review
3H1SimpleSaving plan gives no confirmation. Tapping "Save plan" after editing step 1 closes the plan editor with no visible message and just jumps staight to the Reminders screen without saying the plan was saved or where to find it.Show a brief confirmation (e.g., toast "Plan saved. Find it under Upcoming"). Label Reminders as the next part of setup (e.g., "Step 2 of 2: Reminders").
3H2ModerateDuring goal creation, users are asked how much time they want to dedicate to their goal using predefined time options. However, these options may not translate well to goals outside of physical activities, such as saving money, learning a language, or developing a long-term habit.Adapt the goal commitment input based on the type of goal. For example, allow users to specify weekly savings for financial goals or time spent practicing for learning goals.
3H2ModerateThe app asks users how frequently they want to work toward their goal during goal creation, but later asks how often they want reminders in the reminder settings. It is unclear whether the frequency refers to how often users should complete their activity or how often they should receive notifications.Clearly distinguish "Goal frequency" from "Reminder frequency." Explain that one determines when users plan to complete their activity, while the other determines when they receive notifications.
3H2ModerateThe lock screen banner says "Time for today's step..." but if you click it you are immediate directed to "Did you finish your run?" and have to choose between "Yes, done" or "Not Today" - there's no middle ground for users to review their goal.Change what clicking the lock screen banner opens, or add a "remind me later" option
3H3Complex"Move it to Saturday morning?" only gives me "Update plan". No ways to say no or pick another day, and the only way out is the back arrow. The Updated plan screen also only has "Looks good".Add a "Keep my plan" button next to "Update plan". Also would be nice to let me tap the Saturday row on Updated plan to change the day or time.
3H3Moderate"Yes, done!" logs the run right away, and the "Nice work!" screen only has "Back to home".Show an "Undo" on Nice work for a few seconds, and also let me unmark a step from the Home screen.
3H3SimpleOn the "Your plan" screen, users can edit existing steps but do not appear to have an option to remove a step entirely. Or after adding one step, the add step option disappearsAdd an option to remove individual steps, with a confirmation or undo option to prevent accidental deletion.
3H3Other screensIn the Upcoming section, users can easily find and edit their individual daily tasks, but there does not appear to be an option to edit their overall goal or its original parameters.Allow users to edit the overall goal, including their deadline, daily time commitment, and other original parameters.
3H4Other screensThe Settings page includes a separate option to configure reminders, even though reminders are also configured during the individual goal setup process. It is unclear how these two reminder settings relate to one another.Clarify the purpose of each setting. Consider managing reminders within each individual goal and using the Settings page for general notification preferences.
3H6ComplexThe weekly review asks "What got in the way this week?" without helping users recall their progress and performance this week first. That information is only in the home screen.Let users review their progress and performance first before asking what went wrong.

04 · Full issue log

All 55 violations

Sorted by severity, then heuristic. The spreadsheet has screenshots and each evaluator's rationale.

Show all 55 issues
SeverityHeuristicTaskProblemSuggested fix
3H1SimpleOn the "Start weekly review: screen, clicking "Looks good" does not appear to trigger an action or provide confirmation that the updated schedule has been saved. also is this button always present or does it show up once a week then disappear?show maybe a tick on the button after you completed the weekly review
3H1SimpleSaving plan gives no confirmation. Tapping "Save plan" after editing step 1 closes the plan editor with no visible message and just jumps staight to the Reminders screen without saying the plan was saved or where to find it.Show a brief confirmation (e.g., toast "Plan saved. Find it under Upcoming"). Label Reminders as the next part of setup (e.g., "Step 2 of 2: Reminders").
3H2ModerateDuring goal creation, users are asked how much time they want to dedicate to their goal using predefined time options. However, these options may not translate well to goals outside of physical activities, such as saving money, learning a language, or developing a long-term habit.Adapt the goal commitment input based on the type of goal. For example, allow users to specify weekly savings for financial goals or time spent practicing for learning goals.
3H2ModerateThe app asks users how frequently they want to work toward their goal during goal creation, but later asks how often they want reminders in the reminder settings. It is unclear whether the frequency refers to how often users should complete their activity or how often they should receive notifications.Clearly distinguish "Goal frequency" from "Reminder frequency." Explain that one determines when users plan to complete their activity, while the other determines when they receive notifications.
3H2ModerateThe lock screen banner says "Time for today's step..." but if you click it you are immediate directed to "Did you finish your run?" and have to choose between "Yes, done" or "Not Today" - there's no middle ground for users to review their goal.Change what clicking the lock screen banner opens, or add a "remind me later" option
3H3Complex"Move it to Saturday morning?" only gives me "Update plan". No ways to say no or pick another day, and the only way out is the back arrow. The Updated plan screen also only has "Looks good".Add a "Keep my plan" button next to "Update plan". Also would be nice to let me tap the Saturday row on Updated plan to change the day or time.
3H3Moderate"Yes, done!" logs the run right away, and the "Nice work!" screen only has "Back to home".Show an "Undo" on Nice work for a few seconds, and also let me unmark a step from the Home screen.
3H3SimpleOn the "Your plan" screen, users can edit existing steps but do not appear to have an option to remove a step entirely. Or after adding one step, the add step option disappearsAdd an option to remove individual steps, with a confirmation or undo option to prevent accidental deletion.
3H3Other screensIn the Upcoming section, users can easily find and edit their individual daily tasks, but there does not appear to be an option to edit their overall goal or its original parameters.Allow users to edit the overall goal, including their deadline, daily time commitment, and other original parameters.
3H4Other screensThe Settings page includes a separate option to configure reminders, even though reminders are also configured during the individual goal setup process. It is unclear how these two reminder settings relate to one another.Clarify the purpose of each setting. Consider managing reminders within each individual goal and using the Settings page for general notification preferences.
3H6ComplexThe weekly review asks "What got in the way this week?" without helping users recall their progress and performance this week first. That information is only in the home screen.Let users review their progress and performance first before asking what went wrong.
2H1ModerateThe week strip on Home only shows Done, Missed and Today. There's no state for a day where you did the 5-min version or moved the step.Add a "Partial" state (like a half-filled green circle) and a "Moved" state, and add them to the legend.
2H1AllsUpcoming shows three goals (Run a half marathon, Wake up at 6 AM, Save for a Japan trip), but Home only has one week strip and one streak, and neither says which goal it's for. With multiple goals, what makes a day "Done" or "Missed"?Either give each goal its own strip and streak with a goal switcher on Home, or show partial days across goals (maybe a ring that fills per goal, "2 of 3 done"). Or tapping a day could also show which goals are done.
2H1ModerateAfter clicking "Not Today," it immediately returns to the home screen and have today's task marked as completed. There is a missing screen/feature for the 5-min where users work on their task.Add a pop-up box in home screen for the 5 min tracking
2H2SimpleDates show up without a year and with a 14-week plan or longer you wouldn't be able to tell which day it actually means.Show the year and how long the plan is. It would also be cool if Trunk could warn me if the deadline is too close for my plan.
2H2SimpleThe goal creation flow appears to assume that users have a specific deadline for completing their goal. However, some users may want to establish an ongoing habit without a defined end dateOffer an option to create an ongoing goal without a deadline, with recurring milestones or progress tracking instead.
2H3ModerateAfter "Save plan", the Reminders screen has no "Skip" or "Not now". The only way forward is "Turn on reminders".Add a "Not now" button under "Turn on reminders".
2H3ModerateThe "Did you finish today's run?" screen has no back or close button.An X in the top corner that goes back to Home but leaves today's step open.
2H4ModerateReminders asks both "How often?" and "Which days?", which overlap each other; picking "Daily" and then choosing specific days is contradictory, and neither is pre-filled from the plan.Make the default reminders the plan's days and times; cut the "How often?" row.
2H4ComplexFor the weekly review, step 1 has a full-width "Next" button at the bottom, step 2 has "Update plan" as a small text link inside the insight card, and Updated plan goes back to a bottom button ("Looks good").Keep the bottom button on step 2 ("Update plan") with "Keep my plan" as a second button.
2H4Other screensHome has two different layouts depending on the path. The shape of the menu bars in the bottom looked different, and there's an app icon next to "Hi Layla" only after clicking "yes, done", while the icon to the right disappeared. Spacing on the Home screen's streak card is inconsistent too. Overall alignment on Home is also mixed: the week labels are centered while most of everything else is left aligned.Make sure the layout and icons of home screens are always the same.
2H4Alls"Plan" refers to two different things. In Task 1, "Your plan" is the 5-step training breakdown (Get set up, Weeks 1- 2, …). In Task 3, "Update plan" leads to "Updated plan," which is only a weekly schedule of days and times (Mon 6:00 AM, Wed 6:00 AM, Sat 8:00 AM) with no steps.Use distinct terms: "Plan" for the step breakdown and "Schedule" for days/times ("Update schedule" --> "Your new schedule")
2H5SimpleWhile editing an individual step, you can still hit the "Save plan" button which takes you to reminders.Disable "Save plan" while in the editing text field for a specific step, or alternatively you could also ask something like "Save changes to step 1?".
2H5SimpleWhen editing the plan, "+ add step" allows users to leave it blank and save it. There is no warning message either.Make it the text entry box force response if users did click add a step.
2H6ComplexUpdated plan shows "Saturday 8:00 am", but not where it moved from (Thursday) or that the time actually also changed. There's no day-by-day schedule before this, since the plan only said "3x a week"."Thursday 6:00 AM → Saturday 8:00 AM", or cross the old one out?
2H6SimpleThe "+" button on Home has no label.Extended button that says "+ New goal", or a label under the icon.
2H6AllsEvery card on Home has the same white background and shadow, whether it's info (streak, week strip, Your journey) or something you act on (Today's step). Upcoming is the same, where goal cards and editable step cards look alike. The only difference is the content and color of the content in the cards.I'd keep the backgrounds consistent color still for the overall design, but maybe diffrentiate using accent bars / chevrons / stronger border?
2H8SimpleThe bold step titles (on Your plan) are time ranges ("Weeks 1–2", "Weeks 3–6"), while the actual steps ("Run/walk 1 mile, 3x a week") are small grey text. Every row also has a big purple pencil button.Make the steps the title with time ranges as small labels above them. Use a lighter pencil (maybe just a light gray icon)?
2H8ComplexStart weekly review is the biggest and boldest button on Home, outweighing Today's step which is what a user actually needs to do that day.Make today's step the main emphasis until it nears the end of the week; maybe turn the weekly review button into a banner / notification towards the end of the week?
2H9SimpleFor New goal, "Break it down" stays greyed out until all fields are filled but there isn't anything to say which one is missing.Error message under the empty field ("Pick a deadline") if they either click into that field and click out or try and click the submit button.
2H10AllsSettings should have a Help or FAQ, because nothing explains how the plan gets made, how streaks are counted etc.A short "How Trunkate works" page in Settings, or a quick onboarding that explains everything.
2H11ComplexChanged row is #69647D on #D9D3FA, which is about 3.9:1 contrast.Use the dark text color (#1C1834) on that row and also a darker "Moved" tag?
2H11AllsGreen used for progress (%) and behind the white checkmarks in the "Done" circles on Home (#2FB487) is around 2.6:1 against white.Darken the green (around #1E7A5A), or put the percentage in dark text next to a green bar?
2H11Moderate"I'll do it later" and "Move to tomorrow" are stacked, and their tap areas would probably overlap by half unless in the hi-fi they are just text taps.Make them two separate buttons.
2H12ComplexWeekly review always starts with "What got in the way this week?" and only gives bad things to pick (Busy, Tired, Weather, Forgot, Other), even when on a 6-day streak."How did this week go?" instead with a positive option like "Went well"!
2H12AllsThe reminder flow offers users a five-minute alternative when they cannot complete their planned activity. However, the interface does not clearly communicate whether this alternative is intended as a smaller version of the goal, a way to maintain a streak, or a replacement for the original activity.Explain the purpose of the five-minute alternative and clearly indicate how completing it affects the user's progress and streak.
1H1ModerateThe streak number is inconsistent. Home says "5 day streak", the "Nice work!" screen after "Yes, done!" says "7 day streak", and "Back to home" shows "6 days in a row".Show the same number everywhere (e.g., "5 → 6 day streak" on Nice work, then 6 on Home). A quick "+1" animation on the streak card would be cool.
1H1ModerateAfter I tap "Yes, done!" on "Did you finish today's run?", Home shows Today's step as "Walk 5 min" with a check instead of "Run 2 miles". "Do a 5-min version" goes to the exact same Home screen.For "Yes, done!", show "Run 2 miles" as checked. Only show the shorter version, labeled clearly (e.g., "Walk 5 min (short version)"), if I actually pick it.
1H1ComplexAfter finishing the weekly review, Home goes back to the old state with nothing about the new Mon/Wed/Sat schedule.Go back to the latest Home and show the change, like a "This week" row with "Sat 8:00 AM (moved)" or a small notif banner that says "Saturday run moved to 8 AM!"
1H1ComplexTrunk's insight on step 2 ("You usually skip your run on Thursdays. Move it to Saturday morning?") doesn't mention what I picked on step 1 and is the same whether I pick "Weather", "Busy" or nothing.Connect the insight to the user's answer: "You picked Weather, and you've missed 2 of your last 3 Thursday runs. Want to move it to Saturday morning?"
1H1Other screensIn Settings, users can turn off streak tracking, but the Home screen does not appear to reflect this change. It is also unclear whether disabling streaks removes both the streak counter and the weekly completion calendar.Clarify what disabling streaks changes and ensure the Home screen updates accordingly.
1H2SimpleThe plan ignores the times you said you could give. If you pick "15 min/day", the plan still says "Build to 6 miles, one long run each week" and "Build to 10 miles", which would take a new runner a lot longer than 15 min. During goal creation, users can select how frequently they intend to work toward their goal, but there does not appear to be a way to establish or check a minimum recommended training frequency for a goal such as preparing for a half marathon.Show time per session on each step. Maybe a "15 min/day is tight for a half marathon by Mar 15. Try 30 min/day or a later date?" if timing isn't realistic?
1H2SimpleThe last time option on New goal says "1hr+ min/day".Change it to "60+ min/day" or "1 hr+/day". Is there a follow-up after 1hr+/day to see exactly how many hours?
1H4ModerateAfter the check-in, Today's step on the Home page says "Walk 5 min" but the time under it says "20 min".Make the time match the step.
1H4AllsWeekly review and Updated plan have a white header bar, but New goal, Your plan, and Reminders make the header match the cream background. The form labels also change ("Goal", "Deadline", "Time" are small labels, "How much time can you give it?", "How often?", "Which days?" are big headings but they ask for the same type of input).Change the style to use one header style and one label style for every form field.
1H4AllsDays of the week are written in different formats: "MTWTHF" or "Mon, Tue, ..." or "Monday, Tuesday, ..."At least, choose one between "MTWTHF" or "Mon, Tue, ..."
1H5SimpleOn New goal, you can select "5 min/day" and "1hr+ min/day" together, or none.Make the chips single select and also keep "Break it down" not clickable until one is selected.
1H5ModerateCan select Daily and Weekly at the same time on Reminders, and "Turn on reminders" works regardless.Make frequency single select (or cut, see H4 above), pre-select the plan's days, and disable the button until at least one day is picked.
1H6Other screensThe Home screen displays a single "Your journey" progress tracker, currently showing 3 miles out of 13.1 miles. However, it is unclear whether this represents total accumulated training distance, the longest distance completed in a single run, or progress toward the final race distance.Add a descriptive label explaining what the distance measures, such as "Longest run completed" or "Total training distance," depending on the actual metric being tracked.
1H7ModerateThe circle next to "Run 2 miles" on Home looks like a checkbox but in the prototype you can't tap it.Make the circle tappable to log the step (and also unloggable / undo).
1H7Other screensThe profile takes two taps to reach, and Account is at the bottom of Settings. Related: the elephant in Home's top-right corner, which is usually a profile pic, doesn't do anything.Make the profile pic on Home open the profile (or dropdown to get to profile).
1H8Other screensThe "Account" section in settings has a single row that's also called "Account"."Profile and sign out" instead or just cut the header.
1H8AllsThe floating "+" button sits right against the full-width "Start weekly review" button on Home and overlaps it after a check-inMake them not overlap. Increase the space between them.
1H10ModerateReminders says "We'll keep it light. You can change this anytime." but where?Something like "You can change this anytime in Settings → Reminders."
0H10Other screensIn the final finished version, it'd be nice to add a tutorial teaching users how to use this app. It is not necessary now for the med-fi but would be nice for the final product.Consider adding one in later iterations.

3 = major · 2 = minor · 1 = cosmetic · 0 = not a usability problem (a note for later)