(A)  Reconstruct and critically comment on the argument in 352d-354a.

OR

(B)  Reconstruct and critically comment on the argument in 445a-e.  Hint:  You should take account of Plato's previous characterization of justice as health and how he defines virtues in Book 4.

NOTE:  It may be extremely difficult to construct a formally valid argument.  Rather, reconstruct the important moves in the argument.  See your TF for details!

Papers should be 3 pages long, double-spaced, and are due Wed., Oct. 18, at the beginning of lecture.