Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
The Epic of Identity
  • Odyssey, 12-24
2
The double story of Odysseus
  • Contending with the outer world and the “others”
  • Contending with the familiar world and the “neighbors”
  • The two-edged protagonist
3
“The homecoming of Odysseus”
  • When, precisely, does Odysseus return?
  • Bodily return in book 12 (p. 233):
    • They hoisted up Odysseus
      unruffled on his bed, under his cover,
      handing him overside still fast asleep,
      to lay him on the sand…
  • How much does that count?
4
“The story / Of that man,” part 2
  • Recognition: “This is Odysseus”
  • Re-establishing Odysseus in all the dimensions of his “extended body”
  • Homecoming a return to the position, the role, of “Odysseus”
  • Strategies of selfhood: negotiating identity
    • Agamemnon, the bad example
5
A scar, an interview, a test, a twang
  • The brooch and the interview (p. 360)
  • The scar (365-8)
  • Odysseus’s bow
  • “Like a musician, like a harper” (404)
  • The bed (435)


6
Camouflage
  • Beggar: parody of the heroic, ritual humiliation
  • An utter denial of the “extended body” (reputation, wealth, associates, most abilities)
  • A series of temporary adopted “selves”
7
Who are you? It depends…
  • “Wandering men tell lies for a night’s lodging” (251)
  • The stories the Stranger tells about himself:
    • To Athena (p. 238)
    • To Eumaios: Krete (252-8)
    • To Eumaois: cloak (262)
    • To the suitors: Egypt (325)
    • To Penelope: Krete, Dodona (358-363)
8
The squid’s ink
  • And the stories told to Alkinoos?
  • A reading-experiment
    • Counter-intuitive, but what if?
    • Our faith in the narrator, in the gods, in Odysseus, in Penelope…

9
Odysseus? The Odysseus?
  • Or “an Odysseus,” as in “he’ll do”?
  • Is identity functional or intrinsic?
  • How known?
    • Individual history
    • Capabilities (Only Odysseus…)
    • Individual networks of relations
    • Marks, possessions
    • Matching the fame (the story) of the hero


10
Signs and scars
  • No writing in the Odyssey?
  • Too bad Odysseus wasn’t a speaker of English: we could read the scar on his thigh as writing, namely the word “I”
  • Through this “writing,” the memory (fame) of Odysseus and the person of the tested stranger merge
  • Putting a body to the name