Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
“The Breath of Kings”
  • October 24, 2002
2
“I am Richard II”
  • … quoth Elizabeth I.
  • -- As if, indeed, the Royal Person were immortal and had survived the years from 1400 to 1600 intact, and bearing the same grudges.
3
Two bodies
  • Blackstone: “the king never dies”
  • The king’s natural body
  • The king’s “body politic”
  • -- in what does this second body consist?
  • Can every ruler say “I am Richard II”?
4
“What is thy sentence then…
  • RICHARD. “Therefore we banish you”
  • BULLINGBROOK. “Your will be done”
  • RICHARD. “The hopeless word of never to return / Breathe I against thee”
  • MOWBRAY. “A heavy sentence… And now my tongue’s use is to me no more…”
  • (I. 3. 139-162)
5
… but speechless death?”
  • RICHARD. “Six frozen winters spent, / Return with welcome home from banishment.”
  • BULLINGBROOK. “How long a time lies in one little word. / Four lagging winters and four wanton springs / End in a word, such is the breath of kings.”
  • (I. 3. 210-214)
6
No virtue like necessity
  • GAUNT. “Think not the king did banish thee, / But thou the king. … Go, say I sent thee forth to purchase honor, / And not the king exiled thee… Suppose… thy steps no more / Than a delightful measure or a dance…”
  • BULLINGBROOK. “Oh, who can hold a fire in his hand / By thinking on the frosty Caucasus? / Or cloy the hungry edge of appetite / By bare imagination of a feast?”   (I. 3. 277-94)
7
Words are utterly real
  • John Austin, How to Do Things With Words (1962)
  • “Speech acts” or “performative utterances”
  • Not exactly true or false, but valid and invalid
  • Conditions
  • Chains of performatives
8
Examples and limitations
  • Promising, commanding, declaring (e.g., war), enfeoffing, sentencing, naming, crowning…
  • Staged “performances” and imitations of speech acts
  • Language and “power”: not either/or, but mutual entanglement and imbrication
  • 2 languages, one “constative,” one “performative”? 2 bodies inherent in all of us?
  • The Elizabethan sensitivity to language



9
 
10
Fair sequence and careless patients
  • “Blank charters”
  • “Inky blots and rotten parchment bonds”
  • “Thy state of law is bondslave to the law”
  • “Take Herford’s rights away and take from time / His charters and his customary rights. / Let not tomorrow then ensue today. / Be not thyself. For how art thou a king / But by fair sequence and succession?” (II. 1. 195-9)
11
“The king is not himself”
  • The king’s “body politic” is made up of speech acts
  • Felicitous or infelicitous? Who decides?
  • BULLINGBROOK. “All my treasury / Is yet but unfelt thanks” (II. 3. 60)


12
What is a “body”?
  • Criteria:
    • Agency
    • Autonomy
    • Relationships (to other bodies, to space, etc.)
    • Consequentialness
  • Richard II anatomizes the king’s multiple body