Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Mental geography
  • November 21, 2002
2
Today’s fun fact
  • Despite a deluge of news about the prospect of a war against Saddam Hussein, only 13% of Americans tested could point Iraq out on a map of the world.
  • 11% of Americans could not find America.
  • 71% of Americans could point out where the Pacific Ocean - the world's largest body of water - was located. Worldwide, three in 10 of those surveyed could not locate the Pacific Ocean.
  • Apart from the Swedes, only 40% or fewer young adults could name China and India as the two countries with a population over one billion.
  • Less than 25% of French, Canadian, Italian, British and Americans could name four countries that officially acknowledged owning nuclear weapons.
  • 58% of Americans know the Taleban and al-Qaeda were based in Afghanistan, compared with 84% of Britons, but only 17% of Americans can locate the country.
  • (courtesy of National Geographic Magazine and BBC News World Edition)
3
Who’s to blame?
4
The homunculus
5
Your results may vary
6
Maps express valuations
7
And relationships
8
Mental maps, memory palaces
  • Monuments (“reminders”)
  • Walkers cut paths through cities
9
Experienced worlds
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
Urban planning: mental maps become territory
  • Palaces, churches, squares, avenues, walls, canals; places of pilgrimage, forbidden places
14
Sei Shonagon’s map (inferred)
  • First dimension: hierarchy (“inside” more powerful than “outside”)
  • Second dimension: gender (“inside” more restricted than “outside”)
  • Exile: “When a woman lives alone, her house should be extremely dilapidated, the mud wall should be falling to pieces, and if there is a pond, it should be overgrown with water-plants”
15
The world map, 1914-present: work in progress
  • The disintegration of the world order laid out in 1815 (Vienna conference, to design post-Napoleonic Europe) and 1884 (Berlin conference, to regularize colonial conquest)
  • Emergence of a new space: “the Third World” (Alfred Sauvy, 1952), the “non-aligned movement” (Bandung conference, 1955)


16
Strictly mental spaces?
  • Shared virtual worlds
  • Geographical annotation programs
  • The metaphor of “cyberspace”: what does it reveal, both in its accuracy and its inaccuracy?
  • Space still defined by social interactions and behavior
17
Map and territory
  • “Space is an order of coexistences, as time is an order of successions” (Leibniz)
  • What’s primary: relation (between things in coexistence or mutual sequence)