Analysis By Gary Langer
 Oct.
2 — On the eve of their first debate Al Gore and
George W. Bush remain in virtual lockstep, with an edge to Gore on the
issues — but to Bush on the question of government’s role in
society. Gore beats Bush
in trust to handle two key issues in this race, education and “protecting
the middle class,” and he also holds an edge in the potentially volatile
issue of oil prices. But while issues count, most voters also express a
philosophical preference for “smaller government with fewer services” —
and that helps Bush. The result: Gore has 48
support from likely voters, Bush 46 percent — essentially a dead heat,
like the 47-47 percent result in an ABCNEWS/Washington Post poll
Sept. 6. (Ralph Nader has 3 percent support, Pat Buchanan 1 percent.) It’s
the closest early-October race in at least 20 years, since the
Carter-Reagan contest of 1980.
Debates
Contrary to conventional
wisdom, debates rarely have a direct, measurable impact on presidential
preference. But the last close race is one of the few exceptions: In 1980
Ronald Reagan went into the first debate trailing by eight points, asked
voters if they were any “better off,” and a few days later led by
three. Whether lightning strikes this time for
either candidate remains to be seen. But it does look like plenty of
eyeballs will be there: 77 percent of likely voters say they plan to watch
the first presidential debate Tuesday night. Another 57 percent plan to
watch the vice-presidential debate Thursday.
It doesn’t take much to move things: If a mere 5 percent of voters moved
one way, it would turn a dead heat into a 10-point gap — which may help
explain the movement in some recent polls. (So may their definition of
likely voters, who in this poll account for 52 percent of the voting-age
population.) Indeed in this survey, 10 percent
of likely voters are still up for grabs — those who don’t have a strong
preference and may change their minds, or are outright undecided. This is
down from 15 percent in early September; more people are settling into
their choices. But there are still more than enough lightly committed
voters to break the race open.
The
Sexes The gender gap remains huge — far bigger
than usual. Women support Gore by a 18-point margin in this poll, 56-38
percent, while men support Bush by 13 points, 53-40 percent. That’s a
31-point gender gap. The average is 13 points in the last five
elections. Gore’s support from women is about
the same as Bill Clinton’s in 1996, and much better than it was the last
time a Democrat lost, 1988. In turn, Bush’s support from men is close to
his father’s in 1988 — and much better than the GOP nominee’s in 1992 or
1996.
 ABCNEWS/Washington Post 10/1  |
| |
Gore |
Bush |
| Women |
56% |
38% |
| Men |
40% |
53% |
| Gap: 31 points |
|
 Exit Poll — 1996  |
| |
Clinton |
Dole |
Perot |
| Women |
54% |
38% |
7% |
| Men |
43% |
44% |
10% |
| Gap: 17 points |
|
 Exit Poll — 1992  |
| |
Clinton |
Bush |
Perot |
| Women |
45% |
37% |
17% |
| Men |
41% |
38% |
21% |
| Gap: 5 points |
|
 Exit Poll — 1988  |
| |
Dukakis |
Bush |
| Women |
50% |
50% |
| Men |
41% |
57% |
| Gap: 16 points |
|
Role of
Government A key reason for the division between
men and women is their differing views of the role of government. Seventy
percent of men prefer “smaller government with fewer services.” Far fewer
women, 48 percent agree; instead women are 21 points more likely to favor
“larger government with many services” or be
undecided. It matters in vote preferences: All
told, 60 percent of likely voters favor smaller government, and they
prefer Bush over Gore by 63-31 percent. Just 32 percent favor larger
government, but they prefer Gore over Bush by 79-16 percent.
 Vote Preference:  |
| Prefer: |
All |
Gore |
Bush |
| Smaller government |
60% |
31% |
63% |
| Larger government |
32% |
79% |
16% |
| These results explain
why the contest is so close despite Gore’s edge on key issues: There’s a
conflict between voters’ preference for Gore on some issues, and their
preference for Bush on the broader size-of-government question. It’s a
classic battle. Given these results, it
shouldn’t be a surprise to see Bush in the debates try to paint Gore as a
“big government Democrat” — or to see Gore echo Clinton’s proclamation
that the age of big government is gone.
Issues As is usual in the absence of
war or a bad economy, a variety of social issues lead the list of voter
concerns this year. Top of the charts has been education, and here Gore
continues to hold the edge. Fifty percent say they trust Gore more than
Bush to handle education; 39 percent prefer
Bush. Gore leads by an even bigger margin,
54-36 percent, in trust to help the middle class — a central theme of his
campaign, and one on which Republican candidates, seen by many as favoring
the wealthy, long have been vulnerable. (Among likely voters with
household incomes of $30,000 to $50,000, Gore leads Bush by five
points.) Gore has an edge on a third and more
recent issue, oil and gasoline prices: He leads Bush in trust to hold them
down, by 45-36 percent. On two other issues
the candidates have battled to a standstill: Taxes, on which Bush has led
in the past, but the two are now tied; and “holding down health care
costs,” also a tie. (In the past, phrased as “improving the health care
system,” Gore has led.)
 Registered Voters on Issues:  |
| Candidate you trust on: |
Gore |
Bush |
Advantage |
| Helping the middle class |
54% |
36% |
Gore +18 |
| Improving education |
50% |
39% |
Gore +11 |
Holding down oil/ gas prices |
45% |
36% |
Gore + 9 |
Holding down health care costs |
44% |
42% |
Gore + 2 |
| Holding down taxes |
43% |
45% |
Gore + 2 |
|
Oil &
Politics As an aside, this poll finds something
of a split opinion on the Clinton administration’s decision to release
some of the government’s strategic oil reserves in an effort to hold down
prices. On one hand, 54 percent support the move. On the other, the same
number, 54 percent, think the main purpose was to help Gore in the
campaign.
Clinton
Fatigue This in turn brings up the broader
question of Bill Clinton, who still looms large over this election. The
nation continues to divide into three groups — those who like Clinton and
his policies; those who dislike Clinton and his policies; and the critical
third group, those who like Clinton’s polices, but dislike him personally.
That third group of Clinton-fatigued voters
is a natural Gore support group on the basis of policy, but he’s had
trouble winning them over in big enough numbers. In this poll 55 percent
of that group favors Gore — enough to make it a close race; not enough for
Gore to break away.
 Vote Preference on Clinton:  |
| |
All |
Gore |
Bush |
| Like Clinton and his policies |
32% |
91% |
7% |
| Dislike him and his policies |
27% |
6% |
87% |
| Like his policies, dislike him |
32% |
55% |
37% |
|
Other
Groups There are significant regional differences
in this poll — a sizable Gore lead in the northeast, a slight Bush lead in
the Midwest, and essentially dead heats in the South and West. Also, it’s
Bush +4 among independents, a key swing voter group; but Gore +13 among
white Catholics, another crucial group. Gore
has a big lead in large cities, with a very small edge to Bush in small
towns and rural areas. In the suburbs Gore holds an 11-point lead in voter
preferences — a dead heat among suburban men, and a 20-point Gore lead
among suburban women.
Close? A final note: Polls are not
predictive and don’t try to be. A close race today does not mean it will
finish close. A look at the last two close races in early October is
instructive: In 1980, Jimmy Carter led Reagan by four points in a Gallup
poll on Oct. 13. It was close, but it didn’t end close: Reagan won by 10
points in an electoral landslide. In 1976, by
contrast, Carter led Gerald Ford by two points on Oct. 4. And that one
stayed close: Carter won the election by just a two-point margin.
Methodology This ABCNEWS/Washington
Post poll was conducted by telephone Sept. 28-Oct. 1, 2000. The
results are based on a random sample of 995 likely voters, drawn from
interviews with 1,801 adults; the issues questions are based on interviews
with a subset of 947 registered voters. The results have a three-point
error margin. Field work by TNS Intersearch of Horsham, Pa.
|
 |
A R C H I V
E  Previous
ABCNEWS Polls
S
I G N M E U P
.gif) Read in every morning for the day’s top political news.
Subscribe to our daily e-mail.
|