History
Consider the story's place in history.
How does this story respond to the technophilia and scientific enthusiasm
of its time?
How is history represented in the story itself?
Science and Technology
What things is science capable of explaining?
Are there things science cannot explain? If so, what are some examples?
Living With/In the Machine
How do characters in the story relate to the technology around them?
How does living with or within the machine change them?
What does it mean to call Vashti's room a "cell" in
a beehive?
How is the body treated in this world?
What does it mean to be in constant contact with the rest of the world?
But to never touch anyone?
Why don't they hear the humming of the machine?
What have the people living with/in the machine given up?
What is atavism?
Distance
How is distance made irrelevant in this world?
What kinds of distance are portrayed?
Consider geographical distance, personal distance, distance from thought.
Why don't people touch one another?
Is it significant that everyplace in the world is the same? If so,
why?
Why is distance from original thought important?
Understanding and Religion
How is it that the Machine is said to have done away with all religion
and superstition?
Why do people begin to worship the Machine?
What is the relationship between understanding and worship?
Ideas
What are "ideas"? Why are first-hand ideas bad?
Why doesn't Greece give Vashti any ideas?
Does our own society idealize the concept of the "idea"?
What might it mean that Kuno gets ideas from the stars?
"Man is the Measure"
Why does Kuno say that his first lesson in rediscovering a sense of
space was "man is the measure"?
How and why might man be the measure of things?
How are the senses important here?
How do others in this society measure their worlds?
"The Imponderable Bloom"
What is the "imponderable bloom" of humanity?
What is essential about our humanity?
What makes us human or special?
How is the body important?
The senses?
For what reason do Vashti and Kuno weep near the end?
The Machine Stops
How does the society react when the Machine begins to break down?
How dependent are they on the Machine?
To what extent does it serve them? To what extent do they serve it?
Why does silence kill?
Will someone start the machine again in the future?
Are humans capable of turning away from technologies that negatively
impact their humanity?
Utopia and Dystopia
What elements of this story seem utopian?
What would make it a dystopia?
How does one tell the difference between a utopia and dystopia?
What is the ultimate goal of a society? What can or should be sacrificed
for this goal?