Assignment 1

A1Needfinding

We rode Caltrain from Palo Alto to South San Francisco and back, and interviewed eight commuters about the self-improvement goals they set and the things that get in the way.

Published8 interviews2 extreme users

01 · Domain

From self-improvement to a focus

Tree diagram: Self Improvement splits into Solo Growth (goal setting, time management) and Social Growth (accountability partners, mentorship). Accountability partners is circled.
We started from self-improvement and narrowed to accountability partners.

Starting domain: self-improvement

We split self-improvement into solo growth (goal setting, time management) and social growth (accountability partners, mentorship), and began our interviews from accountability partners.

02 · Methodology

Eight interviews on a train

Participants

Eight commuters across a range of ages and professions.

Location

Caltrain, Palo Alto to South San Francisco and back. We interviewed anyone willing.

Extreme users

A licensed mental health therapist, and an entrepreneur with a family.

Apparatus

Our questions and phone voice memos.

Roles

Usually an interview lead plus a second interviewer for follow-ups. Some interviews were solo.

What we asked

  • What self-improvement goals have you worked on?
  • What problems have you run into?
  • What motivates you, and what has helped?
  • How do you quantify success?
  • Do you respond better to soft or hard reinforcement?
IntervieweeInterviewer
PeterBen
BobRoland
IshmailJosh & Ben
AnneFadumo & Roland
EmilyBen & Fadumo
RohanJosh & Ben
IsabelleJosh
MaryFadumo (no recording)

03 · Interview results

Who we met

Names are pseudonyms.

Extreme user

"Peter", 34, mental health therapist

Lives in San Jose. Swims, watches Netflix, mindful of eating and exercise.

"The only thing that really has been helpful is just making sure that I'm kind of completing the task through the sticky note."

Non-user

"Anne", 43, legislative aide and organizer

Lives in San Francisco. Plays video games and travels a lot.

"Goals, those are different than tasks or to-dos, and I don't track them at all, which is why I never achieve them."

Average user

"Bob", 34, marriage and family therapist

Peter's partner. Swims, reads, games, loves cats. Measures success by workouts per week.

"It's kind of nice being told what to do when I get to the pool."

Low / non-user

"Ishmail", 22, software engineer

Recently moved to San Francisco, newly engaged. Exercises four times a week without tracking.

"It's so hard to find someone equally as strong or equally as weak as you."

Also interviewed

"Emily", 40s, owns a beauty agency in New York · "Rohan", 42, entrepreneur with kids (extreme user) · "Isabelle", 26, genetic counselor · Mary, 23, Stanford student.

Who we reached

Ages 23 to 43, a 50/50 gender split, students, professionals and parents, and White, South Asian, Latin and Muslim backgrounds.

Where they live

San Francisco, San Jose and New York, with long stretches in Texas, Colombia and Massachusetts.

04 · Empathy maps

What they say, think, do and feel

Peter's empathy map: says, thinks, does and feels sticky notes.
Peter: tired after work, motivated by small rewards.
Anne's empathy map.
Anne: overwhelmed by tools, distrustful of AI.
Bob's empathy map.
Bob: to-do lists in the notes app, planned hobbies get done.
Ishmail's empathy map.
Ishmail: believes real change needs outside pressure.

05 · Key insights

From observation to inference

FromObservationInference
Peter, BobWrite to-do lists on sticky notes or in Apple Notes.Writing down what to do helps get it done.
Bob, IshmailA job was the first life goal; then goals turned to wellbeing and enjoyment.Self-improvement goals change before and after getting a job.
Ishmail, Peter, BobOnly used or recommended apps for quantifiable goals.Apps work best for tracking quantifiable improvement.
AllStruggle to balance time across commitments.Saving time, or working within it, could help habits stick.
Peter, BobLack of energy was the main reason Peter missed habits.Solving low energy removes a big barrier.
Anne, Bob, PeterContent with life because of work and social life.Supporting professional and social goals may improve wellbeing.

06 · Summary

Five key learnings

01

Quantified progress motivates

02

Rewards drive progress

03

Tech-averse people need one simple function

Or an alternative in the real world.

04

Consistency is the hardest part

It's worn down by lack of time and energy.

05

Work and social progress matter

They're meaningful goals that raise life satisfaction.

Reflection

  • The script gave us a base; we fit 8 interviews into 2 hours.
  • People were surprisingly willing to talk.
  • We adapted with open-ended how and why follow-ups.

Slides

The full A1 presentation

Use the arrows, the thumbnails or your keyboard's arrow keys.